Gleeson wants 165 homes on South Lakes land set aside for jobs

Gleeson has proposed 165 homes on sixteen acres at Oxenholme in the South Lakes, on land previously allocated for employment development. As Place North West reported, the site had been earmarked for jobs rather than housing.

The trade-off nobody likes making

This is a genuinely difficult planning question and it is worth sitting with rather than picking a side quickly.

Employment allocations exist because a place that builds only houses becomes a dormitory. Residents commute out, local businesses cannot find premises to expand into, and the tax base and the daytime economy both weaken. Councils protect employment land precisely because it is easy to lose and almost impossible to get back: once housing is built on it, it is gone permanently.

Against that, an employment allocation that sits undeveloped for years delivers nothing at all. Some sites are allocated for uses the market will never take up, because the location does not work for occupiers, or because the plan was written in a different economy. Holding land empty in the hope of jobs that are not coming is its own kind of failure.

The honest test is whether this site has genuinely failed to attract employment interest over a sustained period, or whether it simply has not been marketed hard because housing is worth more per acre. Those look identical from the outside and lead to opposite conclusions.

Oxenholme’s specific position

Oxenholme sits just outside Kendal and has something most of the South Lakes does not: a West Coast Main Line station, with direct services to London, Manchester and Scotland, and the branch to Windermere.

That makes it unusually well connected for a settlement of its size, and it cuts both ways in this argument. Good rail access is a genuine asset for employment uses. It also makes the location attractive for housing, particularly for people who commute or work partly from home.

The South Lakes housing problem

There is a strong case for housing here that goes beyond the usual numbers. The South Lakes has one of the most distorted housing markets in England, with high prices driven by second homes and holiday lets, and local wages that come nowhere near supporting them. Young people who grew up in the area routinely cannot afford to stay in it.

Gleeson is relevant to that, because its model is specifically low-cost homes aimed at first-time buyers on modest incomes, typically priced well below regional averages. In a market like the South Lakes, that is a different proposition from a standard executive housing scheme.

The question the council has to answer is whether homes people can actually afford, on land meant for jobs, is a better outcome for Oxenholme than an empty allocation. The published detail does not give the affordable proportion or tenure, and on this site more than most, that is the number that settles the argument.


The North is FU7URE’s briefing on the people, capital and infrastructure reshaping the North of England. Subscribe to the free newsletter to get it in your inbox.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *