Barnsley is set to approve two housing schemes totalling 340 homes. As Place Yorkshire reported, Keepmoat has 126 homes recommended for approval and Vistry 214.
Two builders, one model
The interesting thing is that both developers work in a similar way, and it is not the model most people picture when they think of a housebuilder.
Keepmoat has built its business almost entirely on brownfield regeneration in partnership with councils and housing associations, typically on land nobody else wanted, in places where sales values are modest. Vistry restructured around what it calls partnerships housing, building at volume for housing associations, local authorities and institutional investors who commit to blocks of homes up front rather than relying on individual buyers.
Both models de-risk delivery in the same way. If a large share of a scheme is contracted before construction starts, the builder can keep going through a weak sales market instead of slowing down to protect prices. That is why these two firms keep appearing in Northern approvals while builders more exposed to open market sales have throttled back.
Vistry appears twice in a fortnight in our coverage, having also taken on the 534-home Bromborough site on the Wirral where affordable homes outnumber market homes.
Why Barnsley
Barnsley sits in the former South Yorkshire coalfield, with land values below the regional average and a housing stock weighted towards older terraced and ex-local authority property. That combination makes it difficult for conventional speculative housebuilding to work: build costs are broadly national, sales values are not.
Partnership and regeneration models bridge that gap, which is why Barnsley gets houses built by firms structured this way and comparatively few by builders relying on high-value open market sales.
What we do not know
The published detail does not give the sites, the tenure split, or the affordable proportion on either scheme. Those are the numbers that decide what these 340 homes actually mean for Barnsley.
It is worth being specific about why. In a district where average earnings are below the national figure, a scheme of market homes for sale serves a different population from one weighted towards social rent, and both get described as housing delivery. With over £2bn of social housing allocations now heading North, including a share for South Yorkshire, the tenure question is more answerable than it was a month ago.
The pattern to watch
Three hundred and forty homes across two applications at one committee is a decent week for any district. Barnsley has also featured recently through Ben Bailey Homes buying permitted land for 113 homes across Barnsley and Doncaster.
Steady approvals of this size, delivered by firms that actually build them out, do more for a borough’s housing supply than a single headline scheme that takes a decade to start.
The North is FU7URE’s briefing on the people, capital and infrastructure reshaping the North of England. Subscribe to the free newsletter to get it in your inbox.
Leave a Reply