Persimmon wins 103 homes at South Kirkby on land taken out of the Green Belt

Wakefield Council has approved 103 homes by Persimmon at South Kirkby, on land released from the Green Belt. As Place Yorkshire reported, the site was formerly Green Belt land.

What “former Green Belt” actually means

This phrase causes more confusion than almost any other in planning, so it is worth being clear. Land does not stop being Green Belt because a developer wants to build on it. It stops being Green Belt when the council reviews its local plan, assesses which land it needs for housing over the plan period, and formally releases specific sites through a public process that includes examination by an independent inspector.

That is what happened here. The decision to release this land was taken at plan-making stage, with consultation, not at the point Persimmon applied. By the time the application arrives, the principle of housing is already settled and the committee is deciding layout, design, access and contributions.

People are often, understandably, angry at the wrong meeting. The meeting that matters is the local plan.

South Kirkby’s position

South Kirkby is a former pit village in the old South Yorkshire and West Yorkshire coalfield, between Wakefield, Barnsley and Doncaster. Places like it lost their economic anchor in the 1980s and have relied since on distribution, manufacturing and out-commuting.

A hundred homes in a village of that size is a meaningful addition, and the argument for it is straightforward: without new housing, the population ages, the school roll falls, and the shops that survive on local trade close. The argument against is equally familiar, and comes down to whether the primary school, the GP list and the roads can absorb it.

The volume builder question

Persimmon is one of the largest housebuilders in the country and has had a difficult decade reputationally, particularly on build quality and on the gap between the affordable housing promised at application and the amount delivered.

The fair position is that scale is not a fault in itself. The North needs volume, and firms of that size are the only ones who can deliver it at pace. What is worth watching is whether the section 106 obligations agreed at approval survive to completion, because renegotiation on viability grounds partway through a build is common and rarely gets reported.

The wider Wakefield picture

Wakefield appears twice in this fortnight’s news, with this approval and with Muse now appointed on Castleford town centre. That is a district doing both halves of the job: adding homes at the edges and putting a development partner into the town centre.

The risk in the coalfield districts has always been becoming a dormitory: houses built, residents commuting out to Leeds for work, town centres steadily emptying. Doing only the first half of that is how it happens.


The North is FU7URE’s briefing on the people, capital and infrastructure reshaping the North of England. Subscribe to the free newsletter to get it in your inbox.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *